Red Eye, or, Security Theater

Red Eye is a solid thriller from the time between 9/11 and smart phones (Spoilers)


There are tells all throughout Red Eye that it came out in 2005, the year that I probably should have seen it. Most jarring to me was early on, when Rachel McAdams’s character tells her cab driver that her flight leaves in 10 minutes, and she still seems to expect to be able to get on even though she hasn’t even reached the terminal.

It also spends a lot of time with the main characters using the air phone that used to come in the back of plane seats, as well as Nokia-style phones and cordless phones at home that people have to actually walk to. One of those people is Brian Cox, who still has brown hair. The passengers in the terminal are still using paper tickets, and they read physical books instead of Kindles.

I had to keep reminding myself that it was from 21 years ago, because neither Rachel McAdams nor Cillian Murphy seem to have aged a day in all that time. So I kept marveling at how the movie had gone way overboard in casting what’s ultimately a solid, tight, but “small” and self-contained thriller, until I remembered that neither of them were that famous yet. The movies that I think of as their breakouts (Mean Girls, The Notebook, and 28 Days Later) had only come out a year earlier. And Cox’s role is important to the story but has minimal screen time. And I noticed Suzie Plakson (from Star Trek) as a sassy flight attendant. The casting didn’t need to go this hard!

The only other thing I knew about Red Eye besides the cast was that it was directed by Wes Craven. So I kept expecting it to go off in a wilder or darker direction than it had any interest in going. It’s easy to forget that the weirdness and meta-textual shenanigans we associate with Craven were in the projects that he’d written; as a director — probably most evident in Scream — he didn’t seem to have any interest in pretense or showy direction, but put all of the focus on efficient and effective storytelling.

It’s hard to articulate without its coming across as condescending, the same way that people dismissively describe Ron Howard’s direction as “workmanlike,” but I think it’s a testament to Craven’s talent that Red Eye is just propulsive storytelling from start to finish, with nothing to distract from the plot and performances.

And there are moments of violence that are perfectly timed with no sense of restraint. A viewer going into the movie completely unaware might think that it’s going to be a romantic comedy, until Murphy’s character takes the mask off and shows immediately what he’s willing to do, in a moment that’s shocking but not gratuitous.

For me, the biggest tell that this was a movie from 2005 was the handling of its assassination target, the deputy secretary of homeland security. We’re introduced to him via a news clip, where he’s making a statement about being tough on terrorism. Watching it in 2026, I immediately thought that of course he’d turn out to be the bad guy, revealed in the last act to have been pulling the strings all along. It never even occurred to me that when this movie was released — and even more so when it was written — that suspicion and mistrust of the DHS hadn’t quite saturated the mainstream to the degree that it would later.

And even watching it now, with a greater awareness of just how far the US would go in the name of the War On Terror, I can’t really fault Red Eye for being copaganda, or even tone-deaf. Audiences probably needed stories like this, where a normal person says “never again!” and goes on to defeat the terrorists, as a kind of catharsis.

Well, I say “normal person,” when it’s actually Rachel McAdams playing a character who’s even more perfect than the actor is in real life. The script goes a little overboard establishing how she’s kind, thoughtful, clever, resourceful, athletic, and preternaturally gifted at working in the hospitality industry. If there are two themes in Red Eye, it’s that “terrorists are bad” and “be nice to people working in customer service.”

Red Eye has been on my to-watch list forever, and I’m not sure exactly why I never got around to seeing it before. Probably because I thought I knew exactly what it was. It turns out that my assumptions were mostly incorrect, because it’s nowhere near as violent or as tense as I’d been expecting. Which is to its credit, I think; it’s a solid thriller that feels almost old-school in its scale and its style. Accessible, engaging, and fun enough that you don’t even think too hard about how implausible it all is.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *